This article highlights some of the problems of the traditional distribuition channel and media for SMEs marketing innovative products, services or solutions. It also shows that the new economy provides the tools to address these problems.
First problem: Costs of inventory or acquisition of knowledge in the long tail
Machinery and equipment manufacturers sometime use distribution structure based on wholesales price, inventory and floor plan agreements made with financial institutions and retailers whereby retailers hold the inventory and incur most of the customer acquisition expenses.
In the traditional supply chain, machinery and equipment manufacturer sells products to the retailer at a fixed unit wholesale price. The retailer holds inventory and sells it to the customers at a fixed unit price. In this model the retailer both takes inventory risk and influences demand by exerting effort. For the retailer, if a product is out of stock, the sale is lost. On the other hand unsold inventory is carried over to the next period incurring holding cost. In this model, the retailer is the sole decision maker who decides on both the stocking quantity and the customer acquisition spending. Therefore the retailer has some power in the chain but he also bears all the inventory-related risk.
This distribution model is not efficient for innovative products, services and solutions specialty machinery and equipment manufacturers.
When inventory or knowledge acquisition costs are low, it may be profitable to sell specialized products, services or solutions. But when these costs are high, retailers focus on popular products letting aside specialized products.
Small retailers, they are generally not organized to implement regional promotion plans generating enough sales of specialty machinery and equipment. The lack of sales at the end of the year often proves the inefficiencies of the traditional distribution model for the specialty machinery and equipment.
As for the large retailers able to capture a major part of the supply chain profits they are usually not interested to carry inventory of specialty machinery and equipment and yet demand high profit margins. Large retailers who can reach large markets and territories are generally not interested to take the inventory or the knowledge acquisition costs and are asking for large margins reducing dramatically the benefits for the supplier.
And so, sales intermediaries are generally looking for 20% of products bringing 80% (1) of sales (see green section on the long tail graph) on small geographical markets, while specialty products, service or solution providers targets clients base located on large territories(see yellow section on the long tail graph).

The traditional supply chain is therefore not efficient for the distribution on 80% of the products representing only 20% of the sales on large territories but on a world market the sales for this 20% (the long tail) can be huge. Entrepreneurs and inventors often see the potential for their products, services and solutions on world markets but often use medias traditionally used to market the 20% of the popular products.
Second Problem: inefficiency of cold calls
In front of the difficulty to find a distributor for a specialty product, suppliers will assign technical sales representatives to make cold calls and participate to trade shows.
Ratios are different for each business and sales representative prospecting new clients but, let's just take the example of prospecting new clients for a specialty equipment of 50 000$.
In this scenario our technical sales rep. costs 30$/hours and works 35 hours a week (annual salary and benefits of 51 450$ and 1715 hours within 49 weeks per year).
In this scenario, technical sales rep would spend his 1715 hours as follow:
- Sales prospection on new markets: 20 hours
- Follow up with clients and quotations: 274 hours
- Business visits : 252 hours
- Trades shows: 100 hours
- Preparation of quotations: 60 hours
- Administration: 49 hours
On a weekly base, in average, it would mean approximately:
- Prospecting new markets: 20 hours
- Follow up with clients and quotations: 5,6 hours
- Business visits : 5.18 hours
- Trades shows: 2 hours
- Preparation of quotations: 1,22 hours
- Administration: 1 hour
From these 294 prospects, 72 (25% )will typically generate visits. From these visits, 15 (20%) will typically be interested to buy and will ask for a quotation in the short term.
In our example, 15 requests for quotation cost 32 400$ for prospecting and trade shows (980 hrs + 100hrs x 30$)
If the business has an historical conversion rate of request for quotation into sales of 30%, this will mean 5 contracts of 50 000 on new markets.
If directs costs (direct material and labor) for these equipments are 50%, the contribution to the fixed costs and profits will be 125 000$
Usually the sales director will have hire expectations of returns on investment for the company.
Third: Problems with trade shows
While large companies are going in average to 25 trades shows per year in the United States in order to get the effective frequency for branding strategy.(2) As trade shows are in fact traditional media requiring at least 4 exposures to have an impact on the audience on new markets.
Studies also show that between 70% and 80% of the leads in a trade show are not followed up.
The efficiency of trade shows are questionable for small businesses going to trade shows once in a while in various markets and especially for SMEs contracting out the their trade show campaign.
The trashow industry is in crisis (See: www.meetingindustrycrisiscenter.org/ ). It is also adapting to the realities of the new economy. (See: www.mpiweb.org/CMS/uploadedFiles/Research_and_Whitepapers/FutureWatch2009.pdf )
SMEs with innovative products need to consider trade shows as one aspect of the comunication plan on new market but not necessarily as the center piece of the export plan.
Third problem: Marketing resources for SMEs
In front of the inefficiencies of traditional supply chain, technical sales representative cold calls and trades shows for SMEs involved in new markets, SMEs will have generally do not have the resources to employ a full time marketing and sales manager able to compensate for these inefficiencies on new markets.
They do not have resources for:
- Push promotion plans reaching out to salary paid sales force;
- Pull promotion plans reaching out to large geographical territories;
- Advertising in traditional media to build their brand year after year in new markets.
New marketing solutions are then required for the marketing of specialty products on a business to business export markets.
Small and medium size businesses are facing challenges in the context of the new economy. One might see the new economy as a source of problems or as the source of solutions. The last point of view is the best. We need to understand the trends and adapt our marketing strategies accordingly.
- The new economy is a knowledge economy: in a knowledge economy, knowledge is a product, in knowledge-based economy, knowledge is a tool;
- The new economy is a digital economy: because of the changing usage patterns of Internet technologies, the cost of transactions has dropped so significantly a firm will tend to expand through outsourcing until the cost of carrying out an extra transaction on the open market become equal to the costs of organizing the same transaction within the firm;
- Virtualization: it started 50 years ago. These technologies give the capacity to manage resources starting from a central point and to share resources for better use. Virtualization generates major competitive advantages. In he past 10 years, virtualization technologies progressed a lot to interconnect;
- Molecularization: Large organizations are becoming fragmented into dynamic clusters of individuals.Inter networking: The most notable example of inter networking is the Internet ;
- Disintermediation: lower transportation costs, central warehousing, ERP, drop ship strategies and call centres facilitate direct sales from producers to users;
- Innovation: the conversion conversion of new ideas into benefits, whether social or economic, becomes the driver of the economy;
- Prosumption: firms using collaboration tools to filter content organize themselves to perform through the performance of a large number of individuals and develop opportunities worldwide;
- Immediacy Companies can no longer afford to concentrate on developing the domestic market first and then seek out foreign markets. The rapid technological diffusion now makes it unlikely that a company can rely on a technological competitive advantages for long.
- Globalization: integration of national economies into the international economy through trade, foreign direct investment, capital flows, migration, and the spread of technology ;
- Convergence: Refers to the evolution of previously distinguishable digitalized information formats, services, applications, networks, and business models in ways that reduce or blend the distinctions. Convergence is driven by the rapid development of digital technology.
- Reduce the costs of inventory or the cost of the acquisition of expertise on large geographical markets;
- Implement pull and push promotions on global markets compensating for the inefficiency of traditional distribution networks and traditional medias;
- Outsource the quest for request for quotations on new markets than to manage the business development (cold calling) and traditional media (trade shows, magazine) costs entirely inside the firm.
- Networks manufacturers to professionals sending opportunities of requests for proposals on export markets
- Follows up and reports sales process to stakeholders.
Manufacturers and their distributors receive opportunities of requests for proposals and take care of the sales process. They acquire new customers they could hardly reach otherwise and pay affiliates only when sales or qualifying actions are completed. The break even of these external sales networks is often reached within two to four sales.
References
1Given a large enough availability of choice, a large population of customers, and negligible stocking and distribution costs, the selection and buying pattern of the population results in a power law distribution curve, or Pareto distribution. This suggests that a market with a high freedom of choice will create a certain degree of inequality by favoring the upper 20% of the items ("hits" or "head") against the other 80% ("non-hits" or "long tail"). This is known as the Pareto principle or 80–20 rule. The Long Tail concept has found a broad ground for application, research and experimentation. It is a common term in online business and the mass media, but also of importance in micro-finance (Grameen Bank, for example), user-driven innovation (Eric von Hippel), social network mechanisms (e.g., crowd sourcing, crowd casting, Peer-to-peer), economic models, and marketing (viral marketing). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Tail
2 The concept of effective frequency is simple: Too much advertising repetition leads to overkill and waste; too little and no results. http://www.imediaconnection.com/content/5899.asp
3 http://ezinearticles.com/?Why-You-Have-to-Urgently-Follow-Up-Your-Trade-Show-Leads&id=2026221
4 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_economies
5 Wikinomics : How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything, Don Tapscott, Anthony D William, 2007. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikinomics
6 http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_hb3265/is_n3_v33/ai_n28631973/?tag=content;col1
7 http://www.iccwbo.org/uploadedFiles/Digital_convergence.pdf